Irrelevant, overlooked, or lost? Trends in 20 years of uncited and low cited K-12 online learning articles

Karen Arnesen, Shea Walters, Michael K. Barbour, Jered Borup

Abstract


In this study, we analyzed a subset of uncited or low cited articles from the data reported in Arnesen, Hveem, Short, West, and Barbour  (2019), who examined the trends in K-12 online learning articles from 1994 to 2016. We identified 62 articles that had 5 or fewer citations, and analyzed them for trends in authorship, publication outlets, dates of publication, and topics that could help explain their low citation numbers. We also analyzed topics to see what contribution they might have made and can still make to the field of K-12 online learning. We found that the majority of these articles had been published in many different, less well-known journals.  We also found that these articles may have attracted fewer readers because they addressed topics that seemed to have a narrow focus, often outside of the United States. The articles were also authored by  both well-known researchers in the field as well as a number of one-time authors. What we did not find were articles that were uninteresting, poorly researched, or irrelevant. Many of the articles described and discussed programs that grappled with and overcame some of the same challenges online learning still faces today: issues of interaction, community, technology, management, etc. Some of the early articles gave interesting insights into the history of K-12 online learning, especially as it involved rural learners and programs. Others addressed less mainstream but still interesting topics such as librarians in online learning, cross-border AP history classes, policies that helped or hindered the growth of online learning, and practical considerations of cost and access.

Keywords


K-12, K-12 online learning, virtual school, cyber school, journal analysis

Full Text:

PDF

References


Arnesen, K. T., Hveem, J., Short, C. R., West, R., & Barbour, M. K. (2019). K-12 online learning journal articles: Trends from two decades of scholarship. Distance Education, 40(1), 32-53. https://doi.org/10.1080/01587919.2018.1553566

Barbour, M. K. (2001). Enrichment opportunities for gifted students in rural areas: Online AP social studies sources. Ohio Council for the Social Studies Review, 37(1), 18-26.

Barbour, M. K. (2002). Bridging the home and school: A case study of one web-enabled technology. International Electronic Journal for Leadership in Learning, 6(11). [No longer available online]

Barbour, M. K. (2005). From telematics to web-based: The progression of distance education in Newfoundland and Labrador. British Journal of Educational Technology 36(6), 1055-1058. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-8535.2005.00574.x

Barbour, M. K. (2007). Who’s researching virtual schools: A case for instructional technologists. Distance Learning 4(1), 7-12.

Barbour, M. K. (2011). The promise and the reality: Exploring virtual schooling in rural jurisdictions. Education in Rural Australia, 21(1), 1-20.

Barbour, M. K. (2018). A history of K-12 distance, online, and blended learning worldwide. In K. Kennedy and R. Ferdig (Eds.), Handbook of research on K-12 online and blended learning (2nd ed.). (pp. 21-40). ETC Press. Retrieved from: https://figshare.com/articles/Handbook_of_Research_on_K-12_Online_and_Blended_Learning_Second_Edition_/6686813

Barbour, M. K., & Kinsella, J. (2003). From Newfoundland to Illinois: The development of an AP European history course for the Illinois virtual high school. Journal of the Illinois Council for the Social Studies, 63, 25-35.

Barbour, M. K., & Mulcahy, D. M. (2013). Examining enrollment trends in schools participating in online learning in Newfoundland and Labrador. The Morning Watch 41(1-2), 66-76.

Barbour, M. K., & Reeves, T. C. (2009). The reality of virtual schools: A review of the literature. Computers and Education, 52(2), 402–416.

Barbour, M. K., Siko, J., & Simuel-Everage, K. (2013). Pictures from an exhibition… of online learning: A creative representation of qualitative data. The Qualitative Report 18(45), 1-15.

Beck, D. (2015). The online school librarian: Roles and responsibilities. TechTrends, 59(3), 77-84. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11528-015-0856-8

Benson, G. (1998). Opening opportunities by closing the distance. High School Magazine, 6(1), 42-43.

Bozkurt, A., Akgun-Ozbek, E., Yilmazel, S., Erdogdu, E., Ucar, H., Guler, E., Sezgin, S., Karadeniz, A., Sen-Ersoy, N., Goksel-Canbek, N., Dincer, G. D., Ari, S., & Aydin, C. H. (2015). Trends in distance education research: A content analysis of journals 2009-2013. The International Review of Research in Open and Distributed Learning, 16(1). Retrieved from http://www.irrodl.org/index.php/irrodl/article/view/1953

Burgess-Watkins, K. (2011). Online learning opportunities for K-12 students in Florida's Nassau County. Distance Learning 8(1), 1-7

Carr-Chellman, A. A. (2015). Back to cyber school. E-Learn Magazine, August. Retrieved from http://elearnmag.acm.org/opinion.cfm?aid=2800834

Cavanaugh, C. (2008). Lessons from K-12 distance education in the U.S.A., 1986-2008. Revista Mexicana de Bachillaerato a Distancia, 1(1). Retrieved from http://revistas.unam.mx/index.php/rmbd/article/download/47163/42441

Cavanaugh, C., Sessums, C., & Drexler, W. (2015). A call to action for research in digital learning: Learning without limits of time, place, path, pace…or evidence. Journal of Online Learning Research, 1(1) 9-15. Retrieved from https://www.learntechlib.org/primary/p/149851/

Clark, T. (2018). Program evaluation in K-12 online and blended learning. In K. Kennedy & R. Ferdig (Eds.), Handbook of research on K-12 online and blended learning (2nd ed.) (pp. 121-132). ETC Press. Retrieved from https://figshare.com/articles/Handbook_of_Research_on_K-12_Online_and_Blended_Learning_Second_Edition_/6686813

Coy, K., & Hirschmann, K. R. (2014), Professional development for special education teachers in virtual schools. International Journal of Dyslexia, 40(1), 17-21.

Curtis, H., & Werth, L. (2015). Fostering student success and engagement in a K-12 online school. Journal of Online Learning Research, 1(2), 163-190. Retrieved from https://www.learntechlib.org/primary/p/150962/

Davis, N. E. (2012). 21st century learning environments in the limelight, including virtual schooling. Computers in New Zealand Schools, 24(1), 70-76. Retrieved from https://www.otago.ac.nz/cdelt/otago063962.pdf

Furey, D., & Murphy, E. (2005). K-12 virtual schools and schooling. The Morning Watch, 32(3-4). Retrieved from http://www.mun.ca/educ/faculty/mwatch/win05/MurphyFurey.htm

Gill, B., Walsh, L., Wulsin, C. S., Matulewicz, H., Severn, V., Grau, E., … Kerwin, T. (2015). Inside online charter schools. Cambridge, MA: Walton Family Foundation and Mathematica Policy Research. Retrieved from http://www.mathematica-mpr.com/~/media/publications/pdfs/education/inside_online_charter_schools.pdf

Goss, M. W. (2011). Georgia Virtual School. Distance Learning, 8(3) 41-45.

Greer, D. L., Crutchfield, S., & Woods, K. (2013). Cognitive theory of multimedia learning, instructional design principles, and students with learning disabilities in computer-based and online learning environments. Journal of Education, 193(2), 41-50. https://doi.org/10.1177/002205741319300205

Greer, D., Smith, S., & Basham, J. (2014). Practitioners’ perceptions of their knowledge, skills and competencies in online teaching of students with and without disabilities. Journal of the American Academy of Special Education Professionals, (Spring-Summer), 150-165.

Hamilton, D. P. (1990). Publishing by–and for–the numbers. Science, 250(4986), 1331-1332. Retrieved from http://www.garfield.library.upenn.edu/papers/hamilton1.html

Haughey, M., & Muirhead, B. (1999). Virtual educations: Implications for society. Open Education Research, 2/3, 13-18.

Hu, M., Arnesen, K., Barbour, M. K., & Leary, H. (2019). A newcomer’s lens: A look at K-12 online and blended learning in the Journal of Online Learning Research 5(1), ###-###.

Jeurissen, M. (2015). Learning Te Reo Maori via online distance education: A case study. Journal of Open Flexible and Distance Learning, 19(1). Retrieved from http://www.jofdl.nz/index.php/JOFDL/article/view/229

Kane, J. J. (2004). My dog ate the disk: An analysis of student and teacher perspectives of an online personal fitness course. Florida Journal of Health, Physical Education, Recreation & Dance, 42(2), 8–12

Kirby, D., & Sharpe, D. (2010). An examination of rural secondary students' post-secondary education decisions. Canadian Journal of Career Development, 9(1), 4-14. Retrieved from http://cjcdonline.ca/wp-content/uploads/2014/11/An-Examination-of-Rural-Secondary-Students-post-secondary-education-decisions.pdf

Kirschner, P. A., & van Merriënboer, J. J. G. (2013). Do learners really know best? Urban legends in education. Educational Psychologist, 48(3), 169–183. https://doi.org/10.1080/00461520.2013.804395

Li, Y., Wu, C., Yan, E., & Li, K. (2018). Will open access increase journal CiteScores? An empirical investigation over multiple disciplines. PLoS ONE, 13(8), 1–21. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0201885

Lim, B., & Kim, S. (2008). Issues and possibilities of CHLS (Cyber Home Learning System): Implications on language education. Multimedia Assisted Language Learning, 11(1), 9-33. Retrieved from http://kmjournal.bada.cc/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/11-1-1Lim.pdf

Lin, C.-H., & Zheng, B. (2015). Teaching practices and teacher perceptions in online world language courses. Journal of Online Learning Research 1(3), 275-303. Retrieved from https://www.learntechlib.org/primary/p/171055/

Lokey-Vega, A., Jorrin-Abellan, I. M., & Pourreau, L. (2018). Theoretical perspectives in K-12 online learning. In K. Kennedy and R. Ferdig (Eds.), Handbook of research on K-12 online and blended learning (2nd ed.). (pp. 65-90). ETC Press. Retrieved from https://figshare.com/articles/Handbook_of_Research_on_K-12_Online_and_Blended_Learning_Second_Edition_/6686813

Lowes, S. (2014). A brief look at the methodologies used in the research on online teaching and learning. In R. Ferdig & K. Kennedy (Eds.), Handbook of research on K-12 online and blended learning (pp. 83-104). Pittsburgh, PA: ETC Press. Retrieved from https://figshare.com/articles/Handbook_of_Research_on_K-12_Online_and_Blended_Learning/6686810

Lowes, S., & Lin, P. (2018). A brief look at the methodologies used in the research on online teaching and learning. In K. Kennedy & R. Ferdig (Eds.), Handbook of research on K-12 online and blended learning (2nd ed.) (pp. 91-110). ETC Press. Retrieved from https://figshare.com/articles/Handbook_of_Research_on_K-12_Online_and_Blended_Learning_Second_Edition_/6686813

Lowes, S., Lin, P., & Kinghorn, B. (2015) Exploring the link between online behaviours and course performance in asynchronous online high school courses. Journal of Learning Analytics, 2(2), 169-194. Retrieved from https://learning-analytics.info/journals/index.php/JLA/article/view/4264

Lueken, M., Ritter, G., & Beck, D. (2015). Value-added in a virtual learning environment: An evaluation of a virtual charter school. Journal of Online Learning Research, 1(3), 305-335. Retrieved from https://www.learntechlib.org/primary/p/150993/

Mann, B., & Barkauskas, N. (2014). Connecting learners or isolating individuals?: The .social justice frames in the cyber charter schools in Pennsylvania. International Journal of Cyber Ethics in Education, 3(2), 39-50.

Mayse, D. (2015). How 7th grade students are using resources for learning in an online science course. Journal of Online Learning Research, 1(3), 337-363. Retrieved from https://www.learntechlib.org/primary/p/149948/

McAuley, A. (1998). Virtual teaching on the tundra. TECHNOS, 7(3), 11-14.

McWatters, G., & Thompson, L. (1997) The EDEN Project: Electronic Distributive Education Network distance education solutions for the mainstream. Journal of Distance Education, 12(1), 277-284. Retrieved from http://www.jofde.ca/index.php/jde/article/view/285/438

Molnar, A., Miron, G., Elgeberi, N., Barbour, M. K., Huerta, L., Shafer, S. R., Rice, J. K. (2019). Virtual Schools in the U.S. 2019. Boulder, CO: National Education Policy Center. Retrieved from http://nepc.colorado.edu/publication/virtual-schools-annual-2019

Murphy, E., & Rodríguez-Manzanares, M. (2008). High school teachers’ beliefs about learner-centred e-learning. E-Learning and Digital Media, 5(4), 384-395. https://doi.org/10.2304/elea.2008.5.4.384

Pettyjohn, T., & LaFrance, J. (2014). Online credit recovery: Benefits and challenges. NCPEA Education Leadership Review of Doctoral Research, 1(1). Retrieved from https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1105728.pdf

Piwowar, H., Priem, J., Larivière, V., Alperin, J. P., Matthias, L., Norlander, B., … Haustein, S. (2018). The state of OA: a large-scale analysis of the prevalence and impact of open access articles. PeerJ, 6, e4375. https://doi.org/10.7717/peerj.4375

Rice, M. F. & Dykman, B. (2018). The emerging research base on online learning and students with disabilities. In K. Kennedy and R. Ferdig (Eds.), Handbook of research on K-12 online and blended learning (2nd ed.). (pp. 189-206). ETC Press. Retrieved from https://figshare.com/articles/Handbook_of_Research_on_K-12_Online_and_Blended_Learning_Second_Edition_/6686813

Russell, G. (2003). The potential and problems of virtual schooling. Welsh Journal of Education, 12(1), 40-52.

Russell, G. (2006). Globalization, responsibility and virtual schools. Australian Journal of Education, 50(2), 140-154. https://doi.org/10.1177/000494410605000204

Ryan, T. G., & Beaulieu, R. (2009) Secondary online education: A review and synthesis of central elements. Turkish Online Journal of Distance Education, 20(1). Retrieved from http://tojde.anadolu.edu.tr/makale_goster.php?id=464

Sakar, A.N., & Ozturk, O. (2011). The “community services” course through distance education: Evaluation of primary school students. Turkish Online Journal of Distance Education, 12(1). Retrieved from http://tojde.anadolu.edu.tr/yonetim/icerik/makaleler/650-published.pdf

Smith, S. J., & Harvey, E. E. (2014). K-12 online lesson alignment to the principles of universal design for learning: The Khan Academy. Open Learning, 29(3), 222–242. https://doi.org/10.1080/02680513.2014.992402

Stevens, K. (1995). Some policy considerations in the changing relationship between area schools and New Zealand rural communities. Social Policy Journal Of New Zealand Te Puna Whakaaro, 5(1). Retrieved from http://www.msd.govt.nz/about-msd-and-our-work/publications-resources/journals-and-magazines/social-policy-journal/spj05/05-school-relationship.html

Stevens, K. (1997). Three dimensions of leadership in a telelearning environment: School networking, collaborative teaching and open administration. The Morning Watch, 25(1-2). Retrieved from http://www.mun.ca/educ/faculty/mwatch/fall97/three.htm

Stevens, K. (2000) Telelearning and the education of rural students in Newfoundland and New Zealand. Géocarrefour, 75(1), 87–92. http://doi.org/10.3406/geoca.2000.2458

Stevens, K. (2001). A four-step process for the development of knowledge-building communities in a digital intranet. Journal of Distance Learning, 6(1), 45-48. Retrieved from http://www.jofdl.nz/index.php/JOFDL/article/view/146

Stevens, K. (2009). Perceptions of educational opportunities in small schools in rural Australia and Canada. Rural Society Journal, 19(2), 118-126. https://doi.org/10.5172/rsj.19.2.118

Stevens, K., & Dibbon, D. (2002). Educational innovation in small communities: The introduction of e-learning to extend student educational and career opportunities. The Innovation Journal, 8(4). Retrieved from http://www.innovation.cc/peer-reviewed/stevens-dibbon.pdf

Tainer, J. A., Abt, H. A., Hargens, L. L., Bott, D. M., Lancaster, F. W., Pannell, J. H., Nuhfer, E. B., McGehee, C. L., Banks, W. A., & Pendlebury, D. A. (1991). Science, citation, and funding. Science, 251(5000), 1408-1411. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.251.5000.1410-b

Tysinger, P. D., Tysinger, J. A., Diamanduros, T. D., & Kennedy, K. (2013). K-12 online learning and the training needs for school psychology practitioners. School Psychology Forum, 7(3), 76-88.

Van Noorden, R. (2017). The science that’s never been cited: Nature investigates how many papers really end up without a single citation. Nature, 552, 162-164. Retrieved from https://www.nature.com/magazine-assets/d41586-017-08404-0/d41586-017-08404-0.pdf

Wang, Y., & Decker, J. R. (2014). Examining digital inequities in Ohio’s K-12 virtual schools: Implications for educational leaders and policymakers. International Journal of Educational Reform, 23(4), 294-314. https://doi.org/10.1177/105678791402300404

West, R.E. (2011). About this article and new series. Educational Technology, 51(4), 60.

West, R. E. (2016). Insights from the journal analysis series: What we have learned about educational technology research. Educational Technology, 56(1), 41-45.

Zawacki-Richter, O., Baecker, E. M., & Vogt, S. (2009). Review of distance education research (2000 to 2008): Analysis of research areas, methods, and authorship patterns. The International Review of Research in Open and Distributed Learning, 10(6), 21-50. Retrieved from http://www.irrodl.org/index.php/irrodl/article/view/741




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.24059/olj.v24i2.2080



Copyright (c) 2020 Karen Arnesen, Shea Walters, Michael K. Barbour, Jered Borup

License URL: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/